Gestão & Produção
https://gestaoeproducao.com/article/doi/10.1590/0104-530x3772-20
Gestão & Produção
Artigo Original

Project management in public-private partnerships: a conceptual framework based on a systematic literature review

Lucas Magalhães; Lucas Baraças Figueiredo; Lucas Torres de Jesus

Downloads: 0
Views: 181

Abstract

Abstract: Despite the increasing number of Public-Private Partnerships projects, the results have shown little effectiveness and difficulties in several aspects of project management. This study performs a systematic literature review combining bibliometric analysis and content analysis to identify the challenges in managing these projects and techniques to overcome them, highlighting the critical success factors for project management. The results indicate an increasing number of researches in the field, but there is still a lack of systematization of the management tools and absence of critical success factors during the accomplishment of this type of project. This study proposes a systematization of these elements throughout the project cycle, allowing project managers to visualize challenges and techniques to increase the results related to the main success factors of each stage.

Keywords

Project management, Public-private-partnerships, Systematic literature review

Referências

Abdul-Aziz A. R. Control mechanisms exercised in Malaysian housing public-private partnerships. Construction Management and Economics. 2012;30(1):37-55.

Akintoye A., Hardcastle C., Beck M., Chinyio E., Asenova D. Achieving best value in private finance initiative project procurement. Construction Management and Economics. 2003;21(5):461-70.

Amponsah C. T., Forbes J. L. Public–private partnerships: critical factors for procurement of capital projects. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Management, Procurement and Law. 2012;165(4):211-21.

Aritua B., Smith N. J., Bower D. Construction client multi-projects–A complex adaptive systems perspective. International Journal of Project Management. 2009;27(1):72-9.

Atmo G., Duffield C. Improving investment sustainability for PPP power projects in emerging economies: value for money framework. Built Environment Project and Asset Management. 2014;4(4):335-51.

Bachy G., Hameri A. P. What to be implemented at the early stage of a large-scale project. International Journal of Project Management. 1997;15(4):211-8.

Bayley M. Channel Tunnel Rail Link: financing and risk transfer. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers. Civil Engineering. 2003;156(5):28-35.

Biesenthal C., Wilden R. Multi-level project governance: trends and opportunities. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(8):1291-308.

Bing L., Akintoye A., Edwards P. J., Hardcastle C. The allocation of risk in PPP/PFI construction projects in the UK. International Journal of Project Management. 2005;23(1):25-35.

Lei nº 11.079 de 30 de dezembro de 2004. Institui normas gerais para licitação e contratação de parceria público-privada no âmbito da administração pública. 2004.

Carbonara N., Costantino N., Pellegrino R. Concession period for PPPs: A win–win model for a fair risk sharing. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(7):1223-32.

Carpintero S., Petersen O. H. Bundling and Unbundling in Public–Private Partnerships: Implications for Risk Sharing in Urban Transport Projects. Project Management Journal. 2015;46(4):35-46.

Carvalho M., Fleury A., Lopes A. P. An overview of the literature on technology roadmapping (TRM): contributions and trends. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2013;80(7):1418-37.

Chang C. Y. A critical review of the application of TCE in the interpretation of risk allocation in PPP contracts. Construction Management and Economics. 2013;31(2):99-103.

Chen M. S., Lu H. F., Lin H. W. Are the nonprofit organizations suitable to engage in BOT or BLT scheme? A feasible analysis for the relationship of private and nonprofit sectors. International Journal of Project Management. 2006;24(3):244-52.

Cheng Z., Ke Y., Lin J., Yang Z., Cai J. Spatio-temporal dynamics of public private partnership projects in China. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(7):1242-51.

Cheung E., Chan A. P. Risk factors of public-private partnership projects in China: comparison between the water, power, and transportation sectors. Journal of Urban Planning and Development. 2011;137(4):409-15.

Chou J. S., Leatemia G. T. Critical Process and Factors for Ex-Post Evaluation of Public-Private Partnership Infrastructure Projects in Indonesia. Journal of Management Engineering. 2016;32(5).

Chou J. S., Pramudawardhani D. Cross-country comparisons of key drivers, critical success factors and risk allocation for public-private partnership projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(5):1136-50.

Chowdhury A. N., Chen P. H., Tiong R. L. Analysing the structure of public–private partnership projects using network theory. Construction Management and Economics. 2011;29(3):247-60.

Clifton C., Duffield C. F. Improved PFI/PPP service outcomes through the integration of Alliance principles. International Journal of Project Management. 2006;24(7):573-86.

Codecasa G., Ponzini D. Public–private partnership: a delusion for urban regeneration? Evidence from Italy. European Planning Studies. 2011;19(4):647-67.

Croom S. Introduction to research methodology in operations management. Researching operations management. 2009:42-83.

Cumming D. Government policy towards entrepreneurial finance: innovation investment funds. Journal of Business Venturing. 2007;22(2):193-235.

Daube D., Vollrath S., Alfen H. W. A comparison of Project Finance and the Forfeiting Model as financing forms for PPP projects in Germany. International Journal of Project Management. 2008;26(4):376-87.

De Clerck D., Demeulemeester E. An ex ante bidding model to assess the incentive creation capability of a public–private partnership pipeline. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(1):117-31.

De Lemos T., Eaton D., Betts M., de Almeida L. T. Risk management in the Lusoponte concession: a case study of the two bridges in Lisbon, Portugal. International Journal of Project Management. 2004;22(1):63-73.

De Schepper S., Dooms M., Haezendonck E. Stakeholder dynamics and responsibilities in Public–Private Partnerships: A mixed experience. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(7):1210-22.

Devapriya K. A. K. Governance issues in financing of public–private partnership organisations in network infrastructure industries. International Journal of Project Management. 2006;24(7):557-65.

Dulaimi M. F., Alhashemi M., Ling F. Y. Y., Kumaraswamy M. The execution of public–private partnership projects in the UAE. Construction Management and Economics. 2010;28(4):393-402.

Edelenbos J., Klijn E. H. Project versus process management in public-private partnership: relation between management style and outcomes. International Public Management Journal. 2009;12(3):310-31.

Edelenbos J., Teisman G. R. Public-private partnership: on the edge of project and process management. Insights from Dutch practice: the Sijtwende spatial development project. Environment and Planning. C, Government & Policy. 2008;26(3):614-26.

Edkins A. J., Smyth H. J. Contractual management in PPP projects: evaluation of legal versus relational contracting for service delivery. Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice. 2006;132(1):82-93.

El-Gohary N. M., Osman H., El-Diraby T. E. Stakeholder management for public private partnerships. International Journal of Project Management. 2006;24(7):595-604.

Flyvbjerg B. Quality control and due diligence in project management: getting decisions right by taking the outside view. International Journal of Project Management. 2013;31(5):760-74.

Fogelberg H., Thorpenberg S. Regional innovation policy and public-private partnership: the case of Triple Helix Arenas in Western Sweden. Science & Public Policy. 2012;39(3):347-56.

Grimsey D., Lewis M. K. Evaluating the risks of public private partnerships for infrastructure projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2002;20(2):107-18.

Guo F., Chang-Richards Y., Wilkinson S., Li T. C. Effects of project governance structures on the management of risks in major infrastructure projects: a comparative analysis. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(5):815-26.

Henisz W. V. J. Governance issues in public private partnerships. International Journal of Project Management. 2006;7(24):537-8.

Henjewele C., Sun M., Fewings P. Comparative performance of healthcare and transport PFI projects: empirical study on the influence of key factors. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(1):77-87.

Heravi G., Hajihosseini Z. Risk allocation in public–private partnership infrastructure projects in developing countries: case study of the Tehran–Chalus toll road. Journal of Infrastructure Systems. 2011;18(3):210-7.

Hughes M. Contractors hurry to finish HSL-Zuid. 2005.

Hwang B. G., Zhao X., Gay M. J. S. Public private partnership projects in Singapore: Factors, critical risks and preferred risk allocation from the perspective of contractors. International Journal of Project Management. 2013;31(3):424-33.

Jacobson C., Ok Choi S. Success factors: public works and public-private partnerships. International Journal of Public Sector Management. 2008;21(6):637-57.

Jefferies M., McGeorge W. D. Using public-private partnerships (PPPs) to procure social infrastructure in Australia. Engineering, Construction, and Architectural Management. 2009;16(5):415-37.

Jin X. H., Zhang G. Modelling optimal risk allocation in PPP projects using artificial neural networks. International Journal of Project Management. 2011;29(5):591-603.

Kakabadse N. K., Kakabadse A. P., Summers N. Effectiveness of private finance initiatives (PFI): study of private financing for the provision of capital assets for schools. Public Administration and Development. 2007;27(1):49-61.

Kayaga S., Zhe L. Analysis of public-private partnerships for China's water service. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Municipal Engineer. 2007;160(1):7-15.

Ke Y., Wang S., Chan A. P., Lam P. T. Preferred risk allocation in China’s public-private partnertship (PPP) projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2010;28(5):482-92.

Ke Y., Wang S., Chan A. P. Risk allocation in public-private partnership infrastructure projects: comparative study. Journal of Infrastructure Systems. 2010;16(4):343-51.

Keck P. Public/private partnerships play increasing role in disaster response. Public Works. 1996;127(13):24-5.

Koops L., Bosch-Rekveldt M., Coman L., Hertogh M., Bakker H. Identifying perspectives of public project managers on project success: comparing viewpoints of managers from five countries in North-West Europe. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(5):874-89.

Kumaraswamy M. M., Morris D. A. Build-operate-transfer-type procurement in Asian megaprojects. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management. 2002;128(2):93-102.

Kumaraswamy M. M., Zhang X. Q. Governmental role in BOT-led infrastructure development. International Journal of Project Management. 2001;19(4):195-205.

Kwak Y. H., Walewski J., Sleeper D., Sadatsafavi H. What can we learn from the Hoover Dam project that influenced modern project management?. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(2):256-64.

Lavlinskii S. M., Panin A. A., Plyasunov A. V. Comparison of models of planning public-private partnership. Journal of Applied and Industrial Mathematics. 2016;10(3):356-69.

Lenferink S., Tillema T., Arts J. Public–private interaction in contracting: governance strategies in the competitive dialogue of dutch infrastructure projects. Public Administration. 2013;91(4):928-46.

Lenferink S., Tillema T., Arts J. Lifecycle driven planning of infrastructure: public and private experiences with more integrated approaches for managing project complexity. European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research. 2014;14(2):82-101.

Li B., Akintoye A. An overview of public-private partnership. 2003:3-30.

Li B., Akintoye A., Edwards P. J., Hardcastle C. Critical success factors for PPP/PFI projects in the UK construction industry. Construction Management and Economics. 2005;23(5):459-71.

Li B., Akintoye A., Edwards P. J., Hardcastle C. Perceptions of positive and negative factors influencing the attractiveness of PPP/PFI procurement for construction projects in the UK: findings from a questionnaire survey. Engineering, Construction, and Architectural Management. 2005;12(2):125-48.

Lilley M. D. G. Sharing Risks and Responsibilities through Public Private Partnerships. Engineers Australia. 2005;77(7):10-2.

Ling F. Y. Y., Ong S. Y., Ke Y., Wang S., Zou P. Drivers and barriers to adopting relational contracting practices in public projects: comparative study of Beijing and Sydney. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(2):275-85.

Liu J., Gao R., Cheah C. Y., Luo J. Incentive mechanism for inhibiting investors’ opportunistic behavior in PPP projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(7):1102-11.

Liu J., Love P. E., Smith J., Regan M., Davis P. R. Life cycle critical success factors for public-private partnership infrastructure projects. Journal of Management Engineering. 2014;31(5).

Liu J., Yu X., Cheah C. Y. J. Evaluation of restrictive competition in PPP projects using real option approach. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(3):473-81.

Liu J., Love P. E., Smith J., Regan M., Palaneeswaran E. Review of performance measurement: implications for public–private partnerships. Built Environment Project and Asset Management. 2015;5(1):35-51.

Liu T., Wilkinson S. Critical factors affecting the viability of using public-private partnerships for prison development. Journal of Management Engineering. 2014;31(5).

Liu T., Wilkinson S. Large-scale public venue development and the application of Public–Private Partnerships (PPPs). International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(1):88-100.

Liu T., Wang Y., Wilkinson S. Identifying critical factors affecting the effectiveness and efficiency of tendering processes in Public–Private Partnerships (PPPs): A comparative analysis of Australia and China. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(4):701-16.

Loosemore M., Cheung E. Implementing systems thinking to manage risk in public private partnership projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(6):1325-34.

Medda F. A game theory approach for the allocation of risks in transport public private partnerships. International Journal of Project Management. 2007;25(3):213-8.

Mistarihi A., Hutchings K., Shacklock A. Differing opinions do not spoil friendships: Managing Public–Private Partnership (Ppp) Infrastructure Projects in Jordan. Public Administration and Development. 2013;33(5):371-88.

Mota J., Moreira A. C. The importance of non-financial determinants on public–private partnerships in Europe. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(7):1563-75.

Osei-Kyei R., Chan A. P. Review of studies on the Critical Success Factors for Public–Private Partnership (PPP) projects from 1990 to 2013. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(6):1335-46.

Padalkar M., Gopinath S. Six decades of project management research: thematic trends and future opportunities. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(7):1305-21.

Pankratz T., Walkenmeyer P. Global trends in PPPs benefit desalination projects. Water and Wastewater International. 2005;20(4):11-2.

Perić M. Implementation of project management in the BOT model of public-private partnership in Croatian tourism. Ekonomski Pregled. 2012;63(9-10):518-40.

Pinto H. A. C., Ang H. G. Estruturação de Projetos de PPP e Concessão no Brasil: diagnóstico do modelo brasileiro e propostas de aperfeiçoamento. 2015.

Pitsis T. S., Sankaran S., Gudergan S., Clegg S. R. Governing projects under complexity: theory and practice in project management. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(8):1285-90.

Quelin B., Cabral S., Lazzarini S. G., Kivleniece I. The Private Scope in Public-Private Partnerships: An International Cross-Sector Study. Business Policy & Strategy. 2014;2014(1):15727.

Rajan T. A., Gopinath G., Behera M. PPPs and project overruns: evidence from road projects in India. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management. 2013;140(5).

Reijniers J. J. A. M. Organization of public-private partnership projects: the timely prevention of pitfalls. International Journal of Project Management. 1994;12(3):137-42.

Roberts D. J., Siemiatycki M. Fostering meaningful partnerships in public–private partnerships: innovations in partnership design and process management to create value. Environment and Planning. C, Government & Policy. 2015;33(4):780-93.

Roumboutsos A., Pantelias A. Allocating revenue risk in transport infrastructure public private partnership projects: how it matters. Transport Reviews. 2015;35(2):183-203.

Santosh Kumar Delhi V., Mahalingam A., Palukuri S. Governance issues in BOT based PPP infrastructure projects in India. Built Environment Project and Asset Management. 2012;2(2):234-49.

Scott W. R. Organisations.. 1981.

Shen L. Y., Platten A., Deng X. P. Role of public private partnerships to manage risks in public sector projects in Hong Kong. International Journal of Project Management. 2006;24(7):587-94.

Singh L. B., Kalidindi S. N. Traffic revenue risk management through Annuity Model of PPP road projects in India. International Journal of Project Management. 2006;24(7):605-13.

Skander D., Préfontaine L. The evolution of control mechanisms. The Journal of Modern Project Management. 2014;1(3).

Skietrys E., Raipa A., Bartkus E. V. Dimensions of the efficiency of public-private partnership. The Engineering Economist. 2008;58(3).

Smyth H., Edkins A. Relationship management in the management of PFI/PPP projects in the UK. International Journal of Project Management. 2007;25(3):232-40.

Takey S. M., Carvalho M. M. Fuzzy front end of systemic innovations: A conceptual framework based on a systematic literature review. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2016;111:97-109.

Tang L., Shen Q. Factors affecting effectiveness and efficiency of analyzing stakeholders’ needs at the briefing stage of public private partnership projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2013;31(4):513-21.

Tang L., Shen Q., Cheng E. W. A review of studies on public–private partnership projects in the construction industry. International Journal of Project Management. 2010;28(7):683-94.

Thamer R., Lazzarini S. Projetos de parceria público-privada: fatores que influenciam o avanço dessas iniciativas. Revista de Administração Pública. 2015;49(4):819-46.

Toor S.-R., Ogunlana S. O. Beyond the ‘iron triangle’: stakeholder perception of key performance indicators (KPIs) for large-scale public sector development projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2010;28(3):228-36.

Treasury H. M. Public private partnerships: the governments approach. 2006.

Van Marrewijk A. Managing project culture: the case of Environ Megaproject. International Journal of Project Management. 2007;25(3):290-9.

Van Marrewijk A., Clegg S. R., Pitsis T. S., Veenswijk M. Managing public–private megaprojects: Paradoxes, complexity, and project design. International Journal of Project Management. 2008;26(6):591-600.

Verweij S. Achieving satisfaction when implementing PPP transportation infrastructure projects: A qualitative comparative analysis of the A15 highway DBFM project. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(1):189-200.

Verweij S. Producing satisfactory outcomes in the implementation phase of PPP infrastructure projects: A fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis of 27 road constructions in the Netherlands. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(8):1877-87.

Wang Y. Evolution of public–private partnership models in American toll road development: learning based on public institutions’ risk management. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(3):684-96.

Wang Y., Liu J. Evaluation of the excess revenue sharing ratio in PPP projects using principal–agent models. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(6):1317-24.

Xu Y., Sun C., Skibniewski M. J., Chan A. P., Yeung J. F., Cheng H. System Dynamics (SD)-based concession pricing model for PPP highway projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2012;30(2):240-51.

Yang J. B., Yang C. C., Kao C. K. Evaluating schedule delay causes for private participating public construction works under the Build-Operate-Transfer model. International Journal of Project Management. 2010;28(6):569-79.

Ye K., Shen L., Xia B., Li B. Key attributes underpinning different markup decision between public and private projects: A China study. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(3):461-72.

Yeo K. T., Tiong R. L. Positive management of differences for risk reduction in BOT projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2000;18(4):257-65.

Yu J. H., Kwon H. R. Critical success factors for urban regeneration projects in Korea. International Journal of Project Management. 2011;29(7):889-99.

Yuan J., Zeng A. Y., Skibniewski M. J., Li Q. Selection of performance objectives and key performance indicators in public–private partnership projects to achieve value for money. Construction Management and Economics. 2009;27(3):253-70.

Yun S., Jung W., Han S. H., Park H. Critical organizational success factors for public private partnership projects–a comparison of solicited and unsolicited proposals. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management. 2015;21(2):131-43.

Zhang H. A redefinition of the project risk process: using vulnerability to open up the event-consequence link. International Journal of Project Management. 2007;25(7):694-701.

Zhang S., Gao Y., Feng Z., Sun W. PPP application in infrastructure development in China: institutional analysis and implications. International Journal of Project Management. 2015;33(3):497-509.

Zhang X. Critical success factors for public–private partnerships in infrastructure development. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management. 2005;131(1):3-14.

Zhang S., Chan A. P., Feng Y., Duan H., Ke Y. Critical review on PPP Research–A search from the Chinese and International Journals. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(4):597-612.

Zhang X., Bao H., Wang H., Skitmore M. A model for determining the optimal project life span and concession period of BOT projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2016;34(3):523-32.

Zou W., Kumaraswamy M., Chung J., Wong J. Identifying the critical success factors for relationship management in PPP projects. International Journal of Project Management. 2014;32(2):265-74.

5e7e41330e8825f238e1a446 gp Articles
Links & Downloads

Gest. Prod.

Share this page
Page Sections